A Matter of Fear

The trailer for a new film put out by Answers in Genesis has recently appeared. The film is called A Matter of Faith. As one can tell from the trailer, it looks and feels a lot like the recent Christian film, God’s Not Dead. When the latter film originally came out I had my reservations and annoyances, some of which I shared with some friends at the pub, but I decided to let the hoopla pass without commenting on it. However, with this new trailer I feel like I have to say something.

These films reek of fear.

Check out the trailer for A Matter of Faith.

And here’s the trailer for God’s Not Dead.

The problem that I have with these films is the silly appropriation of the same trope: Christians versus educators. The attitude is Christians contra mundum. Christians versus the philosophers and Christians versus the scientists. If debates are what you want, watch a real debate. Don’t watch a scripted exchange where Christians defeat fictional foes. There is nothing about this trope that is helpful; Christians should be ashamed of the anti-intellectualism on display. This particularly bugs me because I attend a quote unquote Secular University. I love the world of academia, and I believe Christians need to be involved as contributing voices in all disciplines. And yet everything about these films smacks of fear: a fear of the academy and fear of education. In these films it is the relatively uneducated Christians who are victorious over the far-more-educated villains. This attitude not only perpetuates the false dichotomy between faith and reason, but it also convinces the broader world that Christians don’t care. These films do not encourage Christians to enter into the world of academia, but rather to see themselves in a constant fight against the educated, and that is what frightens me.

John Anthony Dunne

You might also enjoy…

  • Empire Criticism of the New Testament with Dr. Laura Robinson and Dr. Justin Winzenburg (Podcast)
    In this episode we’re discussing Empire Criticism and the New Testament with Dr. Laura Robinson and Dr. Justin Winzenburg. Dr. Laura Robinson teaches NT as…
  • Undertone with special guest Dr. Kutter Callaway (Podcast)
    In this episode we discuss the A24 film about a podcast dedicated to discussing alleged paranormal activity, Undertone. For this conversation we’re joined by Dr….
  • Backrooms with Special Guest Dr. Brandon Grafius (Podcast)
    In this episode, we talk about the hit horror film from earlier this year, Backrooms (2026). For this discussion, we’re joined by Dr. Brandon Grafius, who is academic dean and professor of biblical studies at Ecumenical Theological Seminary in Detroit, Michigan, and the author of Concerning Dust and Ashes: Affects of Horror in the Hebrew Bible (Oxford University Press). Over the course of our conversation, we talk about what the Backrooms represent, shared trauma, the horror of endless monotony, and what the Backrooms signal about the future of Horror films. Team members on the episode from The Two Cities include: Dr. John Anthony Dunne.
  • Obsession with special guest Dr. Laura Robinson (Podcast)
    Carrying on with spooky season, in this episode, we discuss the 2026 film, Obsession. We’re joined by a special guest, Dr. Laura Robinson, who teaches NT as an adjunct at Butler University and Christian Theological Seminary, co- hosts the New Testament Review podcast, writes at her Substack, Not Peer Reviewed, and has a forthcoming publication called That’s Not What the Bible Says (Eerdmans). Over the course of our conversation, we discuss monkey paw stories, possession narratives, wish fulfillment, coercion, and what “love” has to do it. Team members on the episode from The Two Cities include: Dr. John Anthony Dunne, Dr. Brandon Hurlbert, and Rev. Dr. Madison Pierce.
  • Widow’s Bay (Podcast)
    In this episode, we’re talking about the Emmy Award-winning show on Apple TV, Widow’s Bay. We discuss our favorite moments, why it’s such a great…
  • Concerning Dust and Ashes with Professor Brandon Grafius (Podcast)
    In this episode, we’re joined by Dr. Brandon Grafius, who is academic dean and professor of biblical studies at Ecumenical Theological Seminary in Detroit, Michigan,…

6 responses to “A Matter of Fear”

  1. Dan

    Very helpful! I too would give all films of this ilk a wide berth; I much prefer to side with Schaeffer in proclaiming Christianity to be the only world view that is fully unified. As he points out, at some point all other philosophies will reach a gap in their reasoning which can only be transcended by a blind leap of faith. As you point out, it’s not Christianity vs reason; it’s an acknowledgement that Christianity is reason, through and through.

  2. Paul

    Bang. Liked your commentary, Dunne.

  3. Brad

    Amen!

  4. Jon

    Thanks for raising this point, John. This sort of attitude makes it difficult for Christians to enter any academic field, let alone make an impact, as we are treated with suspicion. I’ve felt judged many times, as though I’m less competent than both academics and those worried fathers (from the first trailer), because it’s assumed that I’m missing something obvious that a non-specialist in their home library could bring to an academic forum with great success. Oy…

  5. […] here the sentiments raised by John Dunne (author of the brilliant Esther and Her Elusive God) in his review of the trailer earlier this month. John […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *