What to Do With Dreams

There was a time when dreams carried weight. God spoke to people in their sleep, sometimes sending angels into a prophet’s unconscious with words of warning or future wonders.

Now God speaks to us in a better Way (Hebrew 1:1-2). Because we have God’s word and the revelation of his Son, the living Word, we need not look to dreams to discover God’s will. Which leaves us to wonder, what place do dreams have in a Christian worldview today?

Scientists still can’t determine why we dream. Yes, they have theories—dreams are the brain’s attempt to interpret random signals, to reconstruct memories, or to empty unneeded, half-developed ideas. But these remain theories. Even theologians haven’t developed a systematic doctrine of dreams.

Here’s the spiritual concern for me: our inability to exercise self-control (a fruit of the Spirit) over our dreams. It’s hard enough to take every thought captive (2 Corinthians 10:5). What of our dream life? How do Christians deal with shameful dreams? Do we take responsibility? Do we pray it away? Do we repent at first light?

Sure, we have minor say in our dreams. Certain scenes slip in based on fleeting thoughts throughout the day. But our contributions are small. In most cases the brain dreams up its own drama. Sometimes entire worlds, places I’ve never seen. Places that, when I wake, I wish I could someday—some night—revisit. It’s extraordinary, really.

But sometimes our minds drag us on unwanted journeys. The mind is a glorious thing, but it’s not yet glorified. In a single night’s sleep I have killed and been killed, slept with a stranger, and sparked a violent high-speed chase through the streets of an unnamed city. Things better left undreamed. Of course, these are mere moments in my eight-hour voyage to morning, but it worries me that this all comes from within. I’m writer, director and star of my own twisted flicks.

Last night I went to bed with a burden, questioning how someone committed to Christ could sleep through such sordid tales several nights in a row. I fell asleep expecting another descent into the dark and bizarre.

God surprised me.

I dreamed I was in church, leading the congregation in worship through music—something I do every Sunday. It’s true, Dolly Parton was there, but we can overlook that for now. She soon disappeared, as people in dreams often do. Anyway, the pews were packed—some familiar faces, some not so familiar—and we started to sing “In Christ Alone.” I heard every note, every word, as if someone had snuck into my room and slipped headphones over my ears as I slept.

Then we burst into a chorus of “No Condemnation,” a song based on Romans 8:1-2: “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death.” Once again, I heard the whole song—even the harmony. Each saint in the ever-growing crowd sang with passion. Eyes closed. Hearts opened. Hands outstretched.

It was something like John’s dream:

After this I looked, and behold, a great multitude that no one could number, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, clothed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands, and crying out with a loud voice, “Salvation belongs to our God who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb!” (Revelation 7:9-10)

And then I woke up.

5:30 a.m. and fresh of the heels of a worship service. And what a profound song choice for one so wearied by the depravity of his dreams! In my mind, in some imagined sanctuary, rang songs to remind me that my hope is in Christ, that there’s no room for wrath in the life of the redeemed.

So I ask again, what’s the use of dreaming? The more I meditate on the Already/Not Yet, the more I think that, in many ways, dreams reflect real life. Not in any New Age sense, but in that we’re truly capable of both wickedness and worship, whether asleep or awake. I see dreams as mirrors of our Christian walk. Extreme examples of what we’re capable of carrying out, from the darkest deeds to the godliest endeavors.

Right now we’re what Martin Luther called simul iustus et peccator: at once a just person and a sinner. In Christ, our redemption is secured but not yet consummated, so we continue to sin even as we’re sanctified. Not everything is as it should be—as it will be—dreams included.

What do you think? Can we worship in our sleep? Does God still invade our dreams? Are we to simply deal with dreams until we die?

This morning I woke with a weight lifted, with an immense love for God, and a reminder that, in Christ, nothing can condemn us—not even our dreams. I want more dreams like that—dreams like John’s. Dreams of worship, singing with the saints, and sweet communion with Christ.

Those are dreams worth coming true.

 

You might also enjoy…

14 responses to “What to Do With Dreams”

  1. John Anthony Dunne

    Bryan, thanks so much for this post. Aside from being well-written, I appreciate the thought-provoking and pastoral concern here. Dreams are so mysterious! I’m as intrigued as you are man. The connection with inaugurated eschatology is really appropriate I think. Its difficult to discern: as we become more sanctified in Christ should our dreams follow the same trajectory? Can they? Very interesting stuff man. Thanks for being vulnerable with this issue for the sake of edifying others!

    1. Bryan Magana

      I think there are more important things to worry about while we’re awake, but thought I’d throw this out there anyway.

  2. So then, we’re assuming full-bore cessationism here? I’m gathering that from your first couple short paragraphs.

    But then, if God “gave you” that dream (which I have no trouble believing), how is that different from Him, in His meticulous providence, well, “speaking” to you? And how does that not contradict cessationism?

    If I’ve unfairly assumed anything, correct away. Also, I don’t at all mean for my little critique to be condescending. Just a clarification point.

    Wonderful thinking, too. I can’t remember the last time I heard a non-charismatic address this issue, and I do appreciate it.

    Andrew Faris
    Someone Tell Me the Story

    1. Bryan Magana

      Andrew, I’m not sure I’m a hardcore cessationist. I just think that, in these days, Christ is the final Word. I’m open to the possibility that God still speaks in surprising ways, especially in areas where the gospel hasn’t yet transformed the culture. But I’m cautious, that’s all.

      My position on the dream: maybe God gave it to me, maybe he didn’t. Don’t get me wrong, I believe in God’s sovereignty over everything (that would have to include dreams), but I don’t know if he was “speaking” to me in this dream any more than he speaks to me in a song, a poem, a sunset. I’m convinced that the clearest way he speaks is through Jesus. Every other message from God (which may very well be imagined) must be measured against what’s absolutely true, and that’s the word, especially the living Word.

      Tricky topic. Thanks for the comment.

  3. Cj

    Are we not at our cores spirit(ual) beings? This part of our being then (like God) doesn’t require sleep. It seems thus plausible that while our body must rest, our spirits need not, and can be engaged in some form of spiritual / soulish reality. Is this not part of the reason many old prayers beg protection through the night watches? I believe that dreams, like sin, illuminate the shape of our souls. They have the powerful potential to push us, pull us deeper into the arms of Christ.

    1. Bryan Magana

      Thanks for joining the conversation.

      Here’s my take: the Bible portrays us as spiritual AND physical beings. The union of body and spirit was God’s initial design for mankind in Eden, and is his final design for us on the new earth. The time that our bodies and spirits are separated (from death until resurrection) is quite an unnatural divorce. The body and spirit were meant for each other.

      With that said, I’m not sure the body/spirit distinction is helpful here. Since dreams take up only a few minutes of sleep each night, it’s safe to say that when we’re asleep, we’re out cold—body and soul.

      Indeed, we’re made in the image of God. But we must not forget all the ways we’re unlike him. The fact that we sleep at all is actually a good example of the differences between us and God, who neither slumbers nor sleeps (Psalm 121:3-4). I’ve written more about this at the links below, if you’re interested.

      http://bryanmagana.blogspot.com/2010/02/glorifying-god-in-our-sleep-part-1.html

      http://bryanmagana.blogspot.com/2010/02/glorifying-god-in-our-sleep-part-2.html

  4. Judith Behunin

    As always, your article is well-written, glad to see you using your talents. I love your reference to the Already/Not Yet and also agree that we’re capable of both wickedness and worship. But I don’t see the necessity to control our dreams. Don’t they come from the subconscious? How can we take responsibility for that? It’d be nice if we could, and maybe some people can, but I don’t know anyone like that. This is a good article, definitely gives us food for though and further conversation. I realize I know very little compared to all these people so well-versed in theological concepts, but it’s great we can share our thoughts and ideas.

    1. Bryan Magana

      Judy, thank you for the encouragement. Your comments are always welcome!

      I think you’re right about not being able to control our dreams. That’s what makes them so mysterious. Since self-control is a fruit of the Spirit, something we should strive for, why can’t we exercise it while we dream? Does this inability keep us humble? Does it remind us that we’re saved by God’s grace, not by our good works? I think those are questions worth asking. I’ve got dozens more, but nothing I need answered tonight.

      Sweet dreams!

  5. Steve

    Great post my friend! Very thought provoking indeed. God could have shaped creation in such a way that our time spent asleep consisted of nothing but elevator music and empty blankness, but he has instead showered us with yet another amazing gift – the gift of dreaming.

    On a related note, have you ever thought about whether or not our need to sleep is a direct result of the fall? Most experts seem to suggest that the primary purpose for sleep is to allow our body time to recover and heal itself; but if there wasn’t a fall our bodies would be perpetually perfect. Hmmmmmm.. Oh well, I’m not going to lose sleep over this. 😛

    1. Bryan Magana

      Well said, Steve-izzle. Keep those classic puns coming!

      Yes, I’ve sometimes wondered if sleep is a result of the fall. Its healing properties definitely hint at it. Check out 1 Corinthians 15:35-49. Based on Paul’s description of our resurrection bodies, it certainly seems like God could someday do away with sleep altogether.

      But I’ve also wondered the opposite. Maybe sleep is simply the mark of being created and not the Creator. Maybe it’s a gift to be enjoyed, both now and on the new earth. I love me some Sunday afternoon naps; I can see enjoying them just as much in glory. Whatever the case, if we do sleep in the life to come, it’ll be perfect sleep. And if we still have dreams, those too will be redeemed.

  6. Peter

    Um, wait a second here…”God speaks to us in a ‘bett’ way than through dreams”? Who taught you your theology? Those in the New Testament had the old testament word, (which still today carries weight), yet God spoke to them with dreams as well…

    It is our job to discern what we see and hear by the spirit and the word. If what we see or hear in our dreams is in accordance with the scriptures, then indeed God may speak through dreams. Who are you to determine HOW God speaks today? Your interpretation of Scriptures and how it relates to dreams is in complete opposition to the Word that I read.

    1. Bryan Magana

      Peter, thanks for reading and commenting. I think I was clear in both the article and the comments thread: Jesus is better than dreams. Whether or not we think our dreams are messages from God, Scripture maintains that God speaks loudest and clearest through his Son. Although dreams really do fascinate me, I’d rather spend time marveling at what’s already been revealed.

  7. I would like to send you Bryan a message as opposed to posting publicly. (it’s kind, I promise) and the email address that is on the bio page is not a working address. is there some option to communicate with you all if discretion is more appropriate?
    thank you!

    1. Bryan Magana

      Sarah, the address works. I’ll send you an email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *