What I’m (Not) Giving Up For Lent (Guest Post)

To be honest, I have always had something of an aversion to Lent. I generally dread this time of year: February drawing to a close, Lent is in full steam, and all my holy friends are giving things up for God. Part of me doesn’t see the connection between not eating chocolate and knowing God more, while another part of me just isn’t enthused about the prospect of giving up things I really like for 40 long days. And of course, there’s also the guilt I feel for my apparent deficiency in holiness. So, the whole thing is a mess.

My freshman year of college, a friend and I decided to give up ketchup for Lent. The choice of this sacrifice should speak more to our love of ketchup than any character flaws it might imply. I embarked on our fast in good faith, but somewhere between the bookends of Ash Wendesday and Easter, I quit. (My friend, I should tell you, remained faithful.) It wasn’t that I couldn’t keep my roving hands from the ketchup bottle; I just didn’t see how abstaining from my favorite condiment in the cafeteria helped me join Christ in the wilderness or embrace my mortality. Discouraged and confused, I figured this was the end of my Lenten adventures.

Obviously, I was missing the point, which is why I am thankful that this year–despite my woeful ignorance and unworthiness–I believe God has given me an invitation to come to understand a little better the spirit behind the season of Lent. A few weeks ago I was having tea (which, for me, means mostly milk and honey) with my friend Emily, and telling her in long, rambling sentences how I feel like I’m supposed to be living my life more intentionally, more thoughtfully, more in alignment with all that I believe to be true and hold to be valuable. After listening to me pour out my heart, she suggested I use the time of Lent to focus on ways to meaningfully shape and structure my time. Although I wasn’t enthused to have my old nemesis, Lent, brought back into the picture, Emily has never given me bad advice, and I spent the following weeks considering her suggestion.

It began to dawn on me that perhaps Lent is not so much a time of self-denial, but of self-giving…of giving oneself diligently to discipline and intentionality and, ultimately, to God and His purpose for us. Lauren Winner writes in her new book Still that busyness is the new sloth. At first this sounds counterintuitive, but think of the laziness with which we allow life’s perpetual motion to pull us mindlessly along. The dictionary defines sloth as a “habitual disinclination to exertion,” and it is slothfulness that I practice when I refuse to expend the energy neccesary to create space in my life for the things that matter. As Winner says, “I am too lazy to do what’s important, or hard, so I stay busy with everything else” (Still, 105). I give myself to the disctractions and hecticness of each day because it does not entail the vast effort required to give myself to God, to Scripture, to personal growth, to loving people. In the end, my busyness is only a curtain to hide my unwillingness to expend myself in a disciplined and meaningful way.

All these thoughts swirled in my head on Ash Wednesday last week. I went to church. I kneeled and confessed my sins, and as the priest of my Anglican congregation crossed my forehead with the ashes to which I’m destined to return, I reflected on my own mortality, and the purpose for which I have been made: to give myself to God and others. Perhaps that is Lent: a space, an opportunity, a merciful reminder found in the Church calendar, not of what we must deny, but of all that we are called to give.

Carolyn Thomas graduated from Biola University with a B.A. degree in Sociology. She currently lives with her husband in Whittier, CA and works full-time as a nanny for three amazing kids. She spends all her spare time reading, and is a proud member of Dumbledore’s Army. 

You might also enjoy…

9 responses to “What I’m (Not) Giving Up For Lent (Guest Post)”

  1. Dan

    Excellent article. I’ve thought the same way for a while now, and have been particularly deterred from adopting the common view of Lent by observing the way in which people will, at the first taste of freedom at the end of the forty days, indulge twice as much in whatever condiment/delicacy they chose to give up. Benefit? I see none.
    I regard Lent more as giving an impetus; there are always things I should be avoiding or habits I should be forming, and just as New Year’s resolutions help me refocus my mind on what I should be targeting next, so Lent reminds me that I’m not there yet and need to continue my efforts.

    1. Carolyn Thomas

      Dan,

      Thank you so much for the feedback. I have definitely noticed similarities between New Year’s and Lent in that they provide that nudging reminder that we’re “not there yet” as you put it. Lent provides a specific–and therefore not overwhelming–amount of time in which to focus on building habits that will hopefully last much longer than Lent. It’s easier to start with 40 days than with the intimidating goal of changing something for the rest of my life! Again, thanks for the insight!

  2. Judith Thomas

    Thanks, Carolyn, for this very thoughtful essay. It’s all too easy to substitute rules for mindful living. Knowing God depends on it.

    1. Carolyn Thomas

      Thanks for the positive feedback, Judith! I like your description “mindful living”–that is definitely something I have been thinking about a lot lately.

  3. Samuel Garcia

    Thank you very much for this thoughtful and challenging post!

    1. Carolyn Thomas

      And thank you for reading it and for the encouragement!

  4. Love this!

    I gave up biting my finger nails for lent and promised that every time I thought about it or caught myself unconsciously doing it, I would pray. I have been praying a lot so far!

    Thanks for sharing and representing the female population 😉

  5. Carolyn Thomas

    Carrie, thanks for the encouragement! Here’s to more prayer in our lives no matter how it comes about, and to many more female posts on The Two Cities!!!

  6. […] involvement in ecological endeavors or “Creation Care”. I’d also recommend Carolyn Thomas’ post on the true meaning of Lent if you care to reflect on the broader Easter tradition as […]

Leave a Reply to Samuel Garcia Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *