UNBIBLICAL!?

Those of you who clicked this post after seeing the picture might think it’s a blog about the NFL’s quarterback protection policies, and my take on a biblical perspective on the matter.

Well, not really. If you are curious about my opinion, I’ll summarize it with this: I can see the concern to protect players who are playing a game (not intentionally risking their lives). But, I’m a Niner’s fan. Obviously, I’m upset that this call cost them the game, and the physics seem to suggest there really wasn’t anything else a defender could have done. End of story.

If that’s all you wanted to think about, you’re done. But, I think what I really want to challenge you to think about will be far more rewarding.

Whether we’re talking football, basketball, soccer, golf, badmitton, curling… or even the business workplace, the sales floor, the board room, the streets, or high school hallways, there’s competition. No one can argue how deeply entrenched competition is in the human psyche, and the fabric and workings of society. All societies.

So, be ready to think about this: Competition, of all kinds, is ungodly.

Let’s start our discussion with Merriam Webter’s help:

com·pe·ti·tion noun \ˌkäm-pə-ˈti-shən\

“ the act or process of trying to get or win something (such as a prize or a higher level of success) that someone else is also trying to get or win : the act or process of competing”

Millard Erickson, in his systematic theology, writes:

“Sin also has massive effects upon the relationships between humans. One of the most significant is the proliferation of competition. Since sin makes on increasingly self-centered and self-seeking, there will inevitably be conflict with others.”[1]

Erickson goes on how to explain, although every contest has a winner and a loser, because the outcome always leaves one wanting, there really are no winners. War is the ultimate, and most devastating example of this conflict.

But, I think I would press Erickson’s definition further. He suggests that sin has increased competition. However, it seems that sin must be the very genesis of competition. Before the Fall of Lucifer, could competition have ever existed? In a Utopic Eden, where everything from the earth’s crust and waters to microorganisms and mankind were created “good,” all operating in their properly created roles in giving their Creator glory, who, or what, was there to compete against? Competition requires an opponent. It requires an adversary. Before the Fall of Lucifer and the fall of man, or even before creation, was God ever in competition with himself? Thus, competition does not exist because it is grounded in the character of God. God is not the author of competition.

Furthermore, Erickson’s statement seems to suggest that it is self-centeredness that makes competition what it is. Our dictionary definition suggests the same. But again, I would take this further. It seems that you could be in competition, even if personal gain and pride were out of the picture. The reward of competition need not be the attaining of a prize. It can simply be to see the defeat, demise, or destruction of your opponent. As you sit down in a three point stance, sweat beaded atop your eye-black, your ice-cold stare, tunnel-visioned and latched onto your opponent, with the pressurized vigor of your coiled strength ready to be unleashed at the hike of the ball to “flat-back” your opponent… this motivation and sensation, which I’m sure many a male and female athlete can recall, and if we’re honest, even savor, is also manifestation of competition at play.

So, all you Tim Tebow’s and Shaun Alexander’s. It’s time to hang up the cleats. If we take the Christian life of sanctification seriously, how can we justify participation (and, the commitment of one’s entire life, if you are a professional athlete) in any competitive activity? Sports to sales, social status to board games, these must all be ruled out.

Or… are they? It is an unsatisfactory to say “well, if you shoot hoops, or sink holes in one, with a good heart, and not with selfish or destructive intentions, its fine- it’s all about your heart.” The best starting point is to recognize that, although competition is not in God’s character, redemption and perfection is. That being said, there are many things that did not occur or exist before the Fall (either of angels and of men). Competition is one of the things in that list. And, ever since, competition must exist, whenever there are opponents. And where as God and his team (the church) are not in it to selfishly win a prize, He, and we, are in it to redeem, restore, to resurrect and to recreate what was once lost and broken.

Because there is competition, there will be a winner and a loser. In the cross, Christ assured that victory, and thus, it is more than appropriate to identify God as a vanquisher and champion. This is the only route by which all things that are rooted in his character can be realized in his created order.

So, the real question we are begging for- can a Christian be justified in playing sports? Although the temptations to competing out of broken motives are intense, sports are an arena, much like the arena of life, where each player has the charge of pursuing what is virtuous, and achieving what is good. In the plan of history, this is the realization of the Kingdom of God and the redemption of the world, which creation now groans for (Rom 8:19-21). Sports, miniture microcosms of this reality, with arbitrary and man-crafted rules, in a way simulate this. In sports, there is a prize- a cup, a crown, a trophy. But the truly virtuous and gospel-driven person competes not to defeat. She competes not to take the prize. He competes to exercise the virtue of striving for perfection in his form, his team, and, the scoreboard.

Paul does use the imagery of athletic rewards, and tells us of the crowns to be attained. However, in light of our process of reconciling a believer’s participation in competition, it seems best to understand  these pictures not as saying that the Christian can compete and strive to win salvation and its benefits as the be-all-end-all themselves. The true goal and end of the Christian life is to lay hold of CHRIST, and  with it His Kingdom, His plan, and His righteousness  (Phil 3:12-14). Thus, what is pursued is not selfish gain, but the realization of God’s promise to redeem and restablish paradise, the reclaiming of what was once lost.

 

 



[1] Erickson, Christian Theology, 2nd Edition, 635-36.

You might also enjoy…

7 responses to “UNBIBLICAL!?”

  1. J.W. Dunne

    First off, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this! The article had a unique way of looking at an everyday, ordinary event in way that I wouldn’t have even thought of.
    Next, would you consider any type of game that puts you in competition to be wrong? (Not even sure if “wrong” is the right word to use here) For example: Scrabble, Monopoly, Clue?
    Being an Elementary Education major, I’m wondering about what kind of games I should have my students play that isn’t putting them in competition with one another. What about the games that I will have my future elementary students play to better learn mathematics and vocabulary words?
    Remember the games that our former high school teachers had us play to study for tests? Like the “Girls vs. Boys” type of games or “This Side vs. This Side”? Should these be outlawed in your opinion? Should we come up with better, more biblical ways to teach our students the concepts in a fun way?
    The aforementioned questions are probably silly in your eyes, but I believe them to be relatively valid and i’d like to hear your thoughts on the matter.

    Thanks again for the post, Tanner! Great read!

  2. I think competition could have existed prior to the fall. Distinguishing between excellencies of attainment is not necessarily sinful. Sports, like all art, creates an opportunity acquired honor without the necessity of violence to the well being of another (the competition is with rules and nobody has to die/lose their lively hood). Just my two cents.

  3. Tanner Gish

    Hey Jacob,

    Thanks for reading! I love the questions you’re asking, because those are exactly the questions going through my head in what has really been months thinking about this. To some, it may seem silly, but like you, I LOVE sports. It can often bring out the best in us. Yet… it can also bring out the worst. The more I thought about the essential nature of athletic competition, and from there, ALL competition (even board games and class games), I really got wanting to find a more satisfying answer than “these things are ok if you do them with the right motives,” since competition did not exist before there was a fall, and an enemy…
    So, to your question “are board and other games wrong?” in my current state of processing, I would say “no…but be Careful!” I would say this (p.s. skip to six for a direct answer to your question):
    1) Competition exists because of the fall. This does not make it morally evil, it is simply what is when you have two opponents or sides.
    2) Be careful- it was pride and the lust for overcoming God that brought competition into existence. If we’re honest, much of the same attitude will likely leak out of us whenever we engage in competition, as we are imperfect beings.
    3) God is perfect, and is about his work of restoring all that is lost. Since competition now exists, executing this plan my very nature means he must overcome and conquer evil, and to bring about the full realization of his kingdom.
    4) It IS ACCEPTABLE, even commendable, when we live and exercise love, peace, gentleness, righteousness (including righteous anger), justice, etc by the power of the Spirit. Exercising these in a broken world by nature means we will be confronting sin, and by his power overcoming it. Thus, competing out of necessity, as God does, is good.
    5) Thus, in the ultimate reality, “ok” participation in competition really does depend on who’s side you’re on.
    6) Board Games/ Sports/ Classroom games: So.. in these examples, we have arbitrary, morally neutral teams. As much as I do not like the Lakers as a Kings Fan, neither team is more Godly or righteous than the other. Same with the thimble vs the dog in monopoly, or boys vs. girls. However, when we make such “games,” we create an opportunity for the corrupt and broken parts of our nature to leak out and surface, and we will compete and seek to win or defeat by these powers. If we approach it seeking to exercise attributes of the spirit in every move and play, it can be ok.

    All in all… I will admit that I’m dangerous close to saying, what I’m trying not to say- that “it all depends on your attitude/ heart” which makes your participation in competition right or wrong. I realize how I’m probably just blurring lines, vs. delineating them. But, my reason for doing so is because I want to make sure the things that I care about are analyzed through the most sincere theological an scriptural lens. I hope, whether you agree or disagree, that we can be partners in that endeavor!

  4. Tanner, great thoughts man….but Id be careful to say what happened before the fall in its entirety.

    Clothes? Nakedness? I cannot imagine you would advocate nude beaches be the norm?

    Likewise- just because we aren’t given a godly picture of competitions existence before the fall doesn’t necessitate in my mind that it didnt exist.

    The pursuit of success? Is that a bad thing? You seem to say it is and I would disagree my man.

    What do we do with King Uzziah in the OT in 2 Chronicles 26? As long as he sought the LORD, God gave him success…how he sought the Lord? It seems to me it was through a pursuit to have the best wine presses, the best army, the best gardens…not separate from a pursuit of the Lord–simultaneously. Better than those around him and when people of surrounding countries of Israel they would say…their God is good.

    Paul also seems to think in Corinthians and Ephesians at the very least its a competition against the world, the flesh and the devil. I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race…competition at its finest. To think of sanctification as a competition seems to be what Paul is promoting. And it seems to me I can be sanctified in sports, business, and in the way I play scrabble.

    But I would say that competition doesn’t end there but carries on into HEAVEN…we are continually being perfected and on many levels pursuing success in heaven…heaven isn’t a stagnate static place, rather its dynamic and I am going to be constantly deepening in who God is for eternity! And I will be doing it with my brothers and sisters in christ and it will be the healthiest perspective of competition and pursuit of success because it is completely void of anything sinful!

    Cannot wait for your response!

    1. Tanner Gish

      D-Money!

      Does anyone still call you that anymore? If not, I’m going to go find all your Richfield kids, and tell them to bring it back!

      Thanks for reading. I’m really glad to see your response. Especially since I think that we are actually pretty much on the same page. I think your example of Uzziah falls exactly in line with how I tried to describe the only way “Chrisitian competition” can be responsibly executed in a broken world. Uzziah, or even Solomon, David, Josiah… and even individuals like Abraham (on his good days) in their stories of success are aspiring to practice and to achieve the highest measures of virtue (some may not like this word choice) or excellence. Even in Uzziah’s example you provide, note, it is an example of the “struggle to attain what is most excellent,” vs. trying to take something from, or to destroy, another.
      This last point may bring up objections from some about war, because YHWH clearly leads His people into war and positions to destroy others in these situations.
      The main point of my personal mental/ spiritual exercise of reflecting on competition (and what I hope for others to do as well) is to pause, and to consider that if we really boil it down, there is probably impure motive and drive behind most of our participation in competition. To answer the point about war- I think it wise to say that all war falls into this, and are examples of both parties with some sort of “baggage” that is less than righteous on both sides. The only “War” where this is not the case, would be the struggle and aspiration for God’s standards in the fight against the flesh, the world, and the slanderer Satan, as referenced in the Pauline verses you mentioned, David. Why is this ok? Because it is competition/ conflict that is required to happen for original holiness and perfection to be restored. In OT war examples, although Israel is far from being perfectly morally good, we can trust that when she did war according to God’s commands, she was in a sense participating in the same spiritual struggle Paul described, as they are being obedient to God’s overarching salvation-historical plan.
      So, what did I do this evening? Went to the Rose Bowl to watch UCLA (sadly) suffer defeat to ASU [ who must be morally evil by virtue of their mascot, right? (j/k…)]. Yet, it this moment, I made sure to try to practice letting my participation in the event of competition as a fan be one that celebrated and rejoiced over the execution of excellence (a valiant 4th down conversion, a spectacular athletic feat, a score, etc), and that sorrowed over failure, but not at the demise, or penalizing, or injury infliction, or desire to obliterate, the other side. Also, realize my little exercise can be compicated by the fact that the men I am rooting for may not be practicing competition in the way I described above. If, in side a UCLA linebacker’s mind, he’s psyching himself up by thinking “that’s it- I’m unleashing it all, and I’m going to destroy whoever get’s in my way”, because my pride is hurt from being kept away from key tackles this whole game,” in a macho no-nonsense sort of way… that’s the sort of tunnel-visioned, less than virtuous “self-talk” I think a careful reflection on competition should prevent us from practicing.
      Am I making any sense? In short, one might point at me and say “you’re just using a lot more words to say- competition and sports are ok, if you do it with the right heart.” I suppose I’m slightly correcting this by saying “yes… but it needs to be more than “right heart”= not being selfish, cruel, or nasty. If “right heart” equals the 1) all out pursuit of excellence (your Uzziah example), or 2) The overcoming of sin and death in order to pave the way for righteousness when it is the unmistakable enemy,” then I’m fine with that definition. To compare it to battling temptation, its similar to saying that battling such isn’t best done by covering your eyes and ducking in the sand. Its best done by turning the eyes upward to Jesus, not just trying to “see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil.” Let our aims in competition be challenged and elevated.

      Please, correct my mistakes or areas of imprecise explanation…

  5. Sarah Jensen

    Tanner, I enjoyed reading the post and comments. It seems like there are many lessons learned in sports / competiton that can be compared to / applied in the Christian life and that make for powerful analogies to greater, more significant things, like pursuing our ultimate reward, Christ himself. I think it would be interesting to look at which aspects of sport / competition are highlighted in those biblical analogies and which actually break down in the analogy and consequently may not be helpful in athletes’ pursuit of Christ. I haven’t fully thought them through yet otherwise I’d be more specific, but it seems like doing so may be helpful in understanding the spiritual formation of athletes / pros and cons of competition. This sort of topic is an ongoing conversation I have had with many of my former teammates so I appreciate you sharing your thoughts!

  6. Ha- few and far between my friend 🙂 But brings back some great memories! No need to bring it back- its reserved a a special few

    Boiled down I do hear you wanting to say its more than simply that competition and sports are ok, if you do it with the right heart….but there seems to be something pure and simple about saying it that way.

    Motives are huge and unbelievably important in my mind to helping sort these things out—I love how you closed it out….

    Competition is good when:

    1) all out pursuit of excellence (your Uzziah example),
    2) The overcoming of sin and death in order to pave the way for righteousness when it is the unmistakable enemy,”

    “To compare it to battling temptation, its similar to saying that battling such isn’t best done by covering your eyes and ducking in the sand. Its best done by turning the eyes upward to Jesus, not just trying to “see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil.” Let our aims in competition be challenged and elevated.”

    Amen- don’t run from playing scrabble, but sanctify scrabble 🙂 It could have been read…didnt think it was your intent…to say stop competing.

    Much love Tanner— check out the Richfield Community Church website and email me and lets connect soon!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *