The Parable of the Janitor, Ecology, & Creation Care

Last week I discussed the implications that Jesus’ resurrection has for the animal kingdom. I concluded that the animals that lived on this earth will be in the new earth and will experience a resurrection just like all of mankind. If you are curious as to how I came to these conclusions you can read that post here. As an extension of last week’s post I’d like to continue a discussion regarding the implications of Easter. This week I’d like to briefly relate Easter to the Green movement and ecology.

If there is a primary metanarrative that signifies the present Zeitgeist it is ecology. Green initiatives are taking place at every level of society. Some people see it as a major inconvenience. Others despise these initiatives and think it is part of some larger conspiracy. Interestingly, I’ve yet to hear a non-Christian complain about the world’s current ecological endeavors. Why is this the case? I think there is something deeply problematic about this.

God originally created everything good and had specific purposes for his creation. With the Fall everything was subjected to futility, yet God’s purposes would not be thwarted. The creation groans with eager longing as Romans 8 tells us, not to be put down like a stray dog, but to experience freedom and liberation. Thus, when God creates new heavens and a new earth this is not creation ex nihilo. This refers to the renewal or restoration of the existing creation. God makes all things new, not all new things. So there is an ontological continuity between this earth and the earth to come.

In this regard ecological efforts are not in vain. However, this does not mean that through ecology we are beautifying the earth for the new earth. Restoration is a unique act of God that will take place in his timing and will be centrally associated with the coming of Jesus; the one who rose from the death of the old creation into the new life of the future creation. In this manner the Resurrection of Jesus provides the clearest analogy for the continuity of this earth and the new earth. Just as there was an empty tomb outside Jerusalem on the first Easter morning – because the body that went into it was the same body that came out – so also this earth will be changed into the new earth. It is like a seed that has been plated in the ground. And just like seeds, both the earth and our bodies will be changed and glorified. One could say, Well if God is going to uniquely act and change this earth, I still don’t see the point of ecological pursuits now. Yet the problem with this line of thinking is that it is utterly foreign to the biblical authors. They did not separate function and ontology. It is precisely because God is doing this great thing that we ought to act a certain way! It never mattered to them that their actions were not the direct cause of renewal. Note Paul’s words at the end of 1 Cor 15. After arguing consistently for the legitimacy of the resurrection he concludes:

Therefore, my beloved, be steadfast, immovable, always excelling in the work of the Lord, because you know that in the Lord your labor is not in vain (1 Cor 15.58 ESV).

Because God is going to act Paul knows that his labor is not in vain. There is a similar analogy here to ecology in light of the earth’s future restoration. Allow me to explain with something of a personal parable.

All of these issues clicked for me once in a restroom in Southern California. I can remember entering the restroom once with some trash in my hand. As I noticed how crummy the conditions of the restroom were I thought to myself that if I decided to drop the garbage on the floor it would not matter since the room was already a mess and the janitor would come eventually anyway. Now, I was never really going to drop my trash on the ground in the restroom, but I was just thinking about whether or not my act of throwing out the trash mattered in light of the current mess. If the janitor is going to come anyways, why bother? As I thought about this I realized how analogous the situation is to a Christian’s involvement in ecological endeavors. Since the janitor will come anyways does that allow someone to throw their garbage anywhere they’d like? The answer is ‘no’ in the restroom and ‘no’ everywhere else in the universe.

What a Christian thinks about janitors might tell you a lot about their theology.

John Anthony Dunne

You might also enjoy…

11 responses to “The Parable of the Janitor, Ecology, & Creation Care”

  1. Jon Baker

    Amazing. I love the connection to janitors, and it’s so profoundly true. Recently, I’ve found myself more often in discussions with Christians about ecology and environmental challenges (“Is it possible we’ll run out of water? Is global warming real?”). I love the dialogue, but the response that always makes me cringe is “Well, that’s too much for me—guess we’ll just hope for the rapture.” These words could be adapted to any eschatology, as I believe you’ve already demonstrated, but the dangerous sentiment is the same. Thanks John, this post is very needed today.

  2. John Anthony Dunne

    Jon thanks for your comment! I’d love to hear more of your thoughts on these sorts of issues from your science background. I haven’t the foggiest idea about how it all works scientifically, but Creation Care is rooted in good biblical theology so I support it. It really is a shame that Christians are the ones who need to be convinced of this!!

  3. This is great. And I love your last sentence, “What a Christian thinks about janitors might tell you a lot about their theology.” Very powerful.

    I am hoping in the future that you could do more work with this in areas of recycling and issues with pollution and oil. Maybe something title, “Should Christians Drive SUV’s?” I think it’s fare to say that most Christians (or people in general) will not feel good about throwing trash on the floor, but for our society today the issue of global warming (with the majority of Christians not believing global warming to be something that is actually happening because many “right” politicians say so) being constantly debated, I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on more specific things. I personally haven’t had a lot of time to think about these issues though I do mostly take public transportation now (and am thinking of getting rid of my car altogether next year). My roommates push us all to recycle everything and we even have a compost bucket. Do you think Christians should be aware of these different things as well?

    1. John Anthony Dunne

      Carrie thanks for commenting. I was intentionally vague about which Green initiatives should be followed and which could be dismissed since I wanted to provide a general theological framework that could provide the rationale for why these initiatives may or my not be good. I also don’t know enough about those issues to address them well, but I look forward to your future post here at The Two Cities on the matter! ; )

      1. Haha, well I don’t know about ME writing on this matter, but again, I did appreciate your general theological framework – it has given me something to think about more.

    2. Andrew Kelley

      Im sure that John will reply, but I just wanted to point out something that Richard Bauckham said at a lecture I went to. He said, “lets assume for a second that 50% of scientists thought that global warming was a genuine threat that could have devastating effects. Now weigh that number against how many of you have fire insurance on your own homes.” Sharp point, and it did a little something to my environmental sensibilities.

      PS I love Garfield

      1. What does it mean if I have renters insurance with fire insurance? 😉

  4. Garrett

    Thanks John,
    This is truly an encouragement for me and a reminder to stay positive toward ecology and creation care. Sometimes I can be negative about taking care of the earth because I focus so much on the curse from the fall and feel like I can’t make a difference. This post made me consider that in taking care of God’s creation, I am not simply cleaning the earth, but honoring God as well. Also, I like the connection of renewal to the resurrection of Jesus. There is still so much beauty in this world and I hope to contribute in a positive manner in creation care, rather than to be withdrawn and not care. Another great post John Dunne…and gonna be honest…I really clicked this link because of the pic haha dig it. Keep posting, I’ll keep reading!

    1. John Anthony Dunne

      Garrett thanks so much for your introspective comment. I’m glad to hear that you found the post encouraging. I’ll definitely keep writing! Thanks for reading my posts. And as far as the picture goes, if you type in ‘janitor’ on google you get loads of Scrubs pictures! : )

  5. […] implications of the Resurrection, both in regards to the future resurrection of animals, and Christian involvement in ecological endeavors or “Creation Care”. I’d also recommend Carolyn Thomas’ post on the true meaning of Lent if you care to […]

  6. […] an ethereal-spiritual “heaven” where disembodied souls commune with God. I wrote “The Parable of the Janitor” to articulate why Christians should be concerned with ecology, “All Dogs Do Go to […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *