Should I Have Babies? A Single Person’s Hopes and Fears

Last Friday Andrew posted about whether or not he and his wife should have children. As I thought about the issues raised – Is it best to wait? When’s the right time? – I tried to think about the issues from the only perspective I can: singleness.

Allow me to be candid for a moment. I always wanted to be a young father. As it stands I may be able to be relatively young when I get married and start having kids, but not as young as I originally had hoped. If I was to get married soon – which is incredibly unlikely – I’d definitely be having the baby question at an early stage. I love kids and I would love to have several of them—I want to make forts and read Harry Potter by flashlight with my kids! I am jealous of the married couples I see at church with their cute little babies. All I can say is that I’m really looking forward to being a daddy.

BUT

One thing I’ve realized is that I’ve never considered the risks involved and have only recently been confronted with some of them: What if either my wife or myself is infertile? What if there is a miscarriage? What if my child has developmental problems? What about the growing rates of Autism? Are these risks enough to make me second guess having children? It is a little daunting to consider all the potential problems that could come from pregnancy. Two of my good friends out here at St Andrews just had their first child and I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about some of these issues throughout the pregnancy.

I think that where these questions really provoke me is when I think about them in a 21st century context; an age filled with all sorts of technological advances. Yet the sad thing is that when certain abnormalities with the growing baby are detected – such as down syndrome – the majority of such pregnancies are terminated. It is estimated that in the UK, Europe, and America, upwards of 90% (and sometimes higher) of women who discover that their child has down syndrome terminate the pregnancy. As a single person who is not married and is not planning on having children anytime soon, I can only imagine what it would be like to receive news from the doctor that my child has a severe disability. The prospect of that sounds absolutely crushing. However, if a doctor gave me advice on abortion I would frankly have to restrain myself from getting physical. My child will have met its first bully.

In college I took a Theology of Suffering class. We had several guests come to our class with severe disabilities for us to interact with and get to know. We also spent time working with Joni Eareckson Tada and the people involved with her ministry. It was an eye-opening experience for me. I saw how lovely, kind, and gracious these people were. Every life is precious and is a gift from God. So as a single person, one with no prospect of having children soon and one who is nervous about various aspects of the developmental process, I look at the opportunity to have children someday – even with all the risks involved – and see it as totally worth it.

John Anthony Dunne

You might also enjoy…

8 responses to “Should I Have Babies? A Single Person’s Hopes and Fears”

  1. Stephanie

    When my husband and I got married we planned on trying for kids right away. I had a child from a previous relationship so it just made sense to us. The first time we got pregnant I miscarried. I cried for months durning which I received seemingly heartless commentary from people like, “At least you already have a kid”, “Good thing it happened now and not after the baby was born”, and my personal favorite, “At least it happened early enough so you weren’t attached”. The second pregnancy I was put on bed rest for six months. We were told that our baby would most likely be born with downs syndrome. My husband, having a heart for the developmentally disabled, was actually excited about that. I declined further testing as abortion was NOT an option and adding stress to my already high-risk pregnancy didn’t seem wise. Our baby girl was born perfectly healthy and without complication. When our daughter was a few months old we decided that we were going to fully trust God in the baby making department. To us, that meant we wouldn’t do anything to medically prevent or provoke pregnancy. Anyone we told this to (with VERY few exceptions), Christian or not, has questioned, made fun of, or flat out told us we are wrong. Most reacted as if our decision was an attack on theirs. We have since given birth to a healthy baby boy and recently suffered one more miscarriage. A few weeks ago we were told that I may not be able to have any more children due to a non life threatening tumor I have. As horrible as news like this may be to some, I can see it as a blessing. What better way to know your done having kids? Had we chosen to wait until our 30’s like most people these days my husband and I may have unknowingly closed that door completely. With any pain we’ve gone through we find great comfort in knowing we trusted HIM. We can look at our three beautiful children and never have the “what-if’s”. We found all the pain and risks worth it.

    1. Andrew Kelley

      You should write a book.

    2. Stephanie,

      I am so sorry to hear about your experiences and the loss of your two children. Thank you so much for sharing your story with us and being so open to ANYTHING God has for you.

      I recently watched the season finale of 20 kids and counting where they take you through the process of Michelle’s miscarriage – in a way it was somewhat healing to me as I was old enough to understand when my mom had two miscarriage’s. If you haven’t seen it yet I highly recommend.

      Carrie

    3. John Anthony Dunne

      Stephanie, thank you so very much for leaving this comment! I really appreciate your story. Thanks for being vulnerable and opening up your story for the benefit and encouragement of others!

  2. Sean T.

    Amen! Every child is a gift and a blessing!

  3. John – thanks for your thoughts! I think in the next few years there will be less and less handicapped children in America, and especially less children with down syndrome. I also think that this will become a great area where Christians can stand apart from this world by showing what is means to truly love one another by not proceeding with doctor recommended abortions due to babies possibly having a disability. Another area Christians can also stand apart is by adopting so many of these abandoned children who have disabilities.

    I think the 90% of down syndrome babies shows us the kind of individualistic behavior that Americans so often suffer with. It’s really a tragedy since so many doctors are oftentimes wrong. My mother was told she should abort my sister 19 years ago because it appeared she had down syndrome. My sister has no disability whatsoever.

    In my field, I am faced with working with patients and families struggling with disabilities every day. Because it is so common in my life I think of it often. I too would be scared to have a child with a disability because I know that it requires hard work… a large amount of hard work… and then to think of what my child would have to go through is almost unbearable. But I have to trust in God’s and I know that He will give me exactly what He has planned to give me. Very important topic for Christians!

    1. John Anthony Dunne

      The fact that doctors are often times wrong is the most disheartening fact to me. I’m also disgusted that people react to disabilities with the instinct ‘kill’ rather than the instinct ‘protect,’ but the fact that many babies were aborted when the baby ends up progressing just fine. The whole issue is a mess and saddens me deeply!

  4. Shantel

    John, it is always refreshing to find that other people are thinking about these things, before there is even a baby being formed. In my Integrative Sem. class we discussed the book Children of Men and how it was written right around the time birth control came along. It seems that the world we live in not only doesn’t want babies born with disabilities but wants them at their convenience because children are a burden, not a blessing. Children of Men gives us a taste of future without kids and it isn’t very pretty. Thanks for writing about this topic! (To clarify, I am not bashing birth control :))

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *